The Problem With "Just Call Us"
If your current booking process is "check availability by phone" or "email us to inquire," you already know the friction:
People don't call anymore. Younger renters especially. They expect to see availability and book online, the way they book everything else. "Call for availability" on your website might as well say "go somewhere else."
Phone hours don't match renter hours. The person planning their kid's birthday party is doing it at 9pm after the kids are in bed. They want to check dates right now. If they can't, they'll look at places where they can.
Email chains take forever. "Is Saturday available?" "Which Saturday?" "The 15th." "What time?" "Afternoon." "We have 1-5pm or 2-6pm available." Three days later, you're still going back and forth.
Your staff hates it. Every availability question is an interruption. Every booking is a multi-step process spread across calls, emails, and paperwork. They have better things to do.
Hawkwood: Hours Lost to Manual Processes
EventBrite + SignUp Genius + Excel spreadsheets, all disconnected from membership data. Hours spent searching spreadsheets. Teams "frustrated by waiting for manual confirmation." After consolidating: unified operations, increased revenue. Read the full story →
What Makes Online Reservations Actually Work
The difference between reservation software people use vs. software they work around comes down to a few things:
The Renter Can Answer Their Own Questions
The most common question is "when is it available?" If someone can see a calendar showing exactly what's open (without calling, without creating an account, without submitting an inquiry) you've eliminated 80% of your booking-related phone calls.
But the calendar needs to be:
- Actually accurate (if staff make side bookings that don't sync, trust breaks immediately)
- Updated in real-time (showing yesterday's availability is worse than useless)
- Easy to read on a phone (because that's where most people will look)
The Booking Process Is Completable
Sounds obvious, but lots of booking systems let you "request" but not actually book. The renter fills out a form, submits it, and then... waits. Hopes someone calls back. Doesn't know if they actually got the slot.
A real reservation means:
- Clear pricing shown before they commit
- Payment or payment method collected upfront
- Immediate confirmation (even if you review it later)
- The slot is held (if approved, it's theirs)
The Paperwork Is Part of the Flow
Rental agreements, liability waivers, insurance requirements: these can't be afterthoughts. If renters book online but then have to come in person to sign papers, you've only solved half the problem.
Digital agreements should be:
- Presented during the booking flow (not in a separate email later)
- Customizable to your specific terms
- Signed electronically and stored with the reservation
- Accessible later if either party needs to reference them
Hawkwood: Automatic Verification Without the Bottleneck
Member-only facilities required staff to verify membership before every booking. Teams were "frustrated by waiting for manual confirmation." After automating: system checks membership instantly, no lookup, no delays. Read the full story →
The Approval Decision
Here's a question you need to answer upfront: does every booking need human review, or can some go through automatically?
Auto-approval works when:
- The renter is a known quantity (member, repeat customer)
- The facility is low-risk (meeting room, not commercial kitchen)
- Payment is collected upfront (committed renters, not tire-kickers)
- Your policies are clearly agreed to during booking
Manual review makes sense when:
- You're renting to unknown parties
- The event type needs vetting (concerts, alcohol, etc.)
- The facility has special requirements or staffing needs
- You need to verify credentials or insurance
The right answer for most organizations: a mix. Auto-approve the routine stuff so staff can focus on reviewing the exceptions.
What We've Seen Work
Organizations start with more review than needed, nervous about giving up control. Within months, most relax. Hawkwood: auto-approve for members, automatic verification built in. "The whole process is easy peasy lemon squeezy now!" (Heather, Programs Coordinator) Read the full story →
Setting Up Your Facilities
Before you turn on online booking, get clear on a few things for each space:
What are your actual rates?
Don't make people guess. If you have different rates for members vs. non-members, residents vs. non-residents, or weekday vs. weekend, work that out and put it in the system. "Call for pricing" undoes the whole point of online booking.
What are your actual hours?
Can the space be booked at 7am? At 10pm? Only during business hours? On holidays? These restrictions need to be in the system, or you'll be manually declining requests that shouldn't have been allowed in the first place.
What do you actually need to know?
Keep your booking form short. Every field you add is friction. Ask for what's genuinely required: event type, expected attendance, contact info. Don't ask for 15 fields if you only look at 4 of them.
What are your actual policies?
Cancellation terms, deposit rules, what happens if they damage something: this should be in your rental agreement, and renters should agree to it during booking, not after.
Common Sticking Points
"Our Renters Won't Use It"
Some will resist. That's fine. You can still take phone bookings. Staff just enter them in the system instead of in a paper calendar. But you'll be surprised how quickly behavior shifts when online booking is easier than calling.
The key is making the online experience genuinely easier:
- They can see availability without waiting
- They can book at any hour
- They get instant confirmation
- They don't have to wait for a callback
"Our Pricing Is Too Complicated"
If you have complex pricing (different rates by time, renter type, facility, season), you need software that handles it. Don't try to simplify your pricing just to fit a simple tool. You'll end up doing manual adjustments on every booking.
Good reservation software lets you set up pricing rules once, then applies them automatically. Member books the gym on a Saturday? Member weekend rate. Non-member books the same slot? Non-member weekend rate. No lookup, no calculation, no mistakes.
"What If They Book and Then Don't Show?"
Collect payment (or at least a card) at booking. This single change cuts no-shows dramatically. People who've paid actually show up.
For larger rentals, a deposit structure works well:
- Deposit at booking (refundable until X days before)
- Balance due before the event
- Damage deposit held separately
"We Need to See the Space Before They Book"
For certain rentals (large events, commercial uses) you might want to meet with the renter first. That's fine, but separate it from the availability question.
Let them see availability and submit a request online. Then schedule the site visit as part of your approval process. They're already committed; you're just verifying the fit.
North Glenmore: Remove the Bottleneck First
PDF forms, manual payment processing, manual email confirmations. 30 hours per cycle dropped to 5 hours. They doubled camp capacity because the bottleneck was gone. Read the full story →
Signs It's Working
A few weeks after launching online reservations, check:
Fewer phone calls about availability. The calendar is doing its job if people stop calling to ask "is Saturday open?"
Faster time to confirmed booking. What used to take 3-5 days of back-and-forth should now happen in minutes.
More bookings outside office hours. Check when reservations are submitted. Evening and weekend bookings are the clearest sign that self-service is working.
Staff doing less coordination, more useful work. If your team is still spending hours on scheduling logistics, something's not set up right.
The goal isn't to remove humans from the process. It's to remove humans from the parts of the process that don't need them, so they can focus on the parts that do.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to common questions about this topic.
Honestly, the terms overlap a lot. Scheduling tends to emphasize internal calendar management (what's happening in your spaces). Reservation focuses more on the external experience (how renters book those spaces). Most modern software does both, so don't get too caught up in terminology. Focus on whether it solves your actual problems.
Most can, and you should use this. Collecting payment at booking (or at least collecting a card) dramatically reduces no-shows and cancellations. The software should handle rental fees, deposits, and any add-on charges in one checkout flow.
Renters read and sign agreements electronically as part of booking. The signature is timestamped and stored with the reservation. It's legally binding, eliminates paper, and means you can find any agreement in seconds instead of digging through filing cabinets.
Yes, and this is a key decision to make upfront. You can auto-approve everything, require approval for everything, or set rules (like auto-approve for members but review requests from new renters). Most organizations start with more review than needed and loosen up over time.

Written by
Matt Elliott
We help community organizations, recreation centers, and nonprofits streamline their operations with software built for how they actually work.
Related Guides
Facility Scheduling Software: What Actually Matters When Choosing One
Honest advice on choosing facility scheduling software for your community center, rec facility, or nonprofit. What features actually matter, what's marketing fluff, and how to avoid common mistakes.
Recreation Center Management Software: What to Actually Look For
Practical guidance on choosing recreation center management software. What problems it really solves, what features matter for rec centers, and how to avoid expensive mistakes.
How to Streamline Facility Booking for Your Recreation Center
A practical guide to reducing the time and frustration of managing facility rentals. What actually works, what's a waste of effort, and how to tell if you're making progress.