The short version
Pick Wild Apricot if you are a club, association or small nonprofit with a few hundred to a few thousand contacts, you need a website, member database, events and email from one vendor, and you want to set it up yourself on a 60-day trial without a contract. Pick Hivebrite if you are an alumni network, foundation, professional network or large association with an annual budget in the five figures, and the reason you are buying is member-to-member engagement: groups, forums, mentoring and a branded mobile app. Pick neither if your week includes hall rentals, kids programs or volunteer shifts: both stop well short of operations.
Where Wild Apricot wins
- Price. $66/mo for 100 contacts, every tier published, no setup fees. Hivebrite starts at $895/mo billed annually.
- Trial and terms. 60-day no-card trial, month-to-month billing, no cancellation fees. Hivebrite is demo only on annual terms.
- Operational membership tools. Dues, renewals, invoices, member bundles, events with registration types and waitlists, a store and donations, all in every tier and mature after fifteen-plus years.
- Website builder at every tier. Drag-and-drop builder, themes, member-only pages, widgets and WordPress embeds. Hivebrite has a no-code page builder, but it is a community portal rather than a general website.
- Mobile apps included. Member and admin apps ship with every plan; Hivebrite's native app is a paid extension.
Where Hivebrite wins
- Community engagement. Groups and sub-communities, forums, messaging, member matching and mentoring programs. Wild Apricot's directory and forums are basic by comparison.
- Unlimited users and flat pricing. No contact counting; plans differ by admin seats and groups (Core: 2 admins, 5 groups; Flex: 5 + 5 admins, 10 groups; Prime: 10 + 10 admins, 25 groups). Wild Apricot bills every contact.
- Chapters and governance. Autonomous sub-communities with governance on Prime, community champions on Flex. Wild Apricot has no multi-chapter structure.
- Enterprise integration. Documented REST API with OAuth2, SSO via SAML, OIDC, Okta and Azure AD, Zapier and Make. Wild Apricot has an API and Zapier/Make but no enterprise SSO.
- No gateway surcharge published. Payments run through Stripe, Braintree, PayPal, Square or Zelle at gateway rates. Wild Apricot adds 20% of your subscription if you bring your own gateway.
Pricing in practice
Wild Apricot is a subscription by total contacts: $66/mo at 100 ($59.40/mo with 1-year prepay, $56.10/mo with 2-year), and third-party listings show about $78 (250), $147 (500), $252 (2,000) and $462 (5,000). Lapsed members and subscribers count, so clean the list first, and budget 20% of the subscription extra if you must keep Stripe or PayPal. Hivebrite is a flat annual plan from $895/mo ($10,740/yr) for Core, with hands-on onboarding included, professional services sized to package, and the native mobile app as an extension. A 2,000-contact association pays about $252/mo on Wild Apricot and at least $895/mo on Hivebrite; the gap only closes if you would otherwise buy a separate community platform, mentoring tool and branded app.
Who should pick which
| If you are... | Lean towards |
|---|
| A club or association under 5,000 contacts that needs a site and dues | Wild Apricot |
| A group that wants to set up and run the tool itself with no contract | Wild Apricot |
| An alumni network or foundation where engagement and mentoring are the product | Hivebrite |
| A large association with regional sub-communities and SSO requirements | Hivebrite Flex or Prime |
| A community league, rec center or club that rents space or runs programs | Neither; see the third option below |
The third option
If you are comparing these two because your current setup no longer fits, check what your organization actually does week to week. Communal was built for groups that run memberships alongside programs, facility rentals, donations and volunteers, and prices by paying members rather than contacts or a flat enterprise plan: $75/mo to 250 members with volunteers, donors and POS included, programs +$50/mo, facilities from +$50/mo, no contract, a 30-day free trial and free migration from either tool. It does not include a website builder, forums or a native mobile app, which is the honest trade.