The short version
Pick Wild Apricot if you are a club or association with a few hundred contacts that wants its public website, member directory, events and email from one vendor, and you are comfortable using the in-house payment processor. Pick Neon CRM if you are a nonprofit with a large or fast-growing database, you want donors, members, events and volunteers in one CRM, and you already have a website. Pick neither if your operations include room rentals, recurring programs or a sports season: both stop at memberships, events and (for Neon) volunteer opportunities.
Where Wild Apricot wins
- Website builder. Drag-and-drop builder, themes, member-only pages, widgets and WordPress embeds. Neon CRM has no site builder.
- Lower entry price. $66/mo for 100 contacts, with 10% off for 1-year prepay and 15% for 2-year. Neon CRM starts at $99/mo and needs $209/mo Impact for memberships.
- Everything in every tier. Events, email, store, donations, member and admin mobile apps at every price point. Neon CRM gates memberships, events, volunteers and API behind Impact.
- Trial and terms. 60-day no-card trial, month-to-month billing, no setup or cancellation fees. Neon CRM has no trial and annual terms are typical.
Where Neon CRM wins
- Unlimited records. Growth does not move you up a tier. Wild Apricot counts every contact, including lapsed members and subscribers.
- Donor CRM depth. Donation pages, tax receipts, workflow automation and reporting built for fundraising, with Neon Pay reconciliation and donor-covered fees. Wild Apricot takes donations but is not a donor CRM.
- Volunteer management. Included from the Impact tier; Wild Apricot has no native volunteer module.
- Published processing rates and no gateway surcharge. Neon Pay is 2.99% + $0.30 per card. Wild Apricot charges 20% of your subscription if you bring your own gateway.
- Open API on Impact and above, with unlimited users, emails and forms.
Pricing in practice
Wild Apricot bills by total contacts in the database: $66/mo at 100, and third-party listings show roughly $78 (250), $147 (500), $252 (2,000) and $462 (5,000). A list clean-up lowers your bill; a newsletter list raises it. Neon CRM is flat by feature tier with unlimited records: $99/mo Essentials covers donations and reporting only, and Impact at $209/mo is the realistic floor for a membership organization. Add payments: Wild Apricot's own processor with unpublished rates, or 20% of your subscription as a surcharge if you keep Stripe or PayPal; Neon Pay at 2.99% + $0.30 per card and 1% + $1 per ACH. For a 300-contact club Wild Apricot is clearly cheaper; for a 4,000-record nonprofit the two are close and Neon's flat price may win.
Who should pick which
| If you are... | Lean towards |
|---|
| A club or association that needs a website and membership from one vendor | Wild Apricot |
| A group under 500 contacts on a tight budget | Wild Apricot ($66/mo to $147/mo) |
| A nonprofit whose database is growing past a few thousand records | Neon CRM (unlimited records) |
| A charity that manages donors, members and volunteers together | Neon CRM Impact or higher |
| A community league, rec center or club that rents space or runs programs | Neither; see the third option below |
The third option
If you are comparing these two because your current setup no longer fits, check what your organization actually does week to week. Communal was built for groups that run memberships alongside programs, facility rentals, donations and volunteers, and prices by paying members rather than contacts: $75/mo to 250 members with volunteers, donors and POS included, programs +$50/mo, facilities from +$50/mo, no contract, a 30-day free trial and free migration from either tool. It does not include a website builder or Neon's donor-retention reporting, which is the honest trade.